Mary Cassatt: The Lady and the Missing Mural
The museum was full, stuffy even. It was a hot day outside and the air was thick, inside the museum too. Someone had just eaten a very garlicky meal that wafted about as I wandered, but that didn’t bother me. I was in my favorite place and garlic is a smell I often enjoy, but prefer outside of a museum setting of course. Mary Cassatt has always been a favorite of mine. She is a trailblazer not only amongst women but also as an American artist in the world of Impressionism. She has always been an inspiration when it comes to my own work, the way she brings attention to the simplicity of life, as well as drawing attention to things most just look past, bringing importance to the roles of women, even the simplest of roles. There was so much wonderful work to see, from her at the Art Institute of Chicago, but I was thrilled to see a special exhibition opening Mary Cassatt: After Impressionism. As I wandered I struggled to pick a favorite. So much of her work pulls on my heart strings and fills my mind with awe and conversation. I couldn’t help but spit out small fun facts I knew about some works to my sister who had tagged along. I stopped to take notes on a few pieces, giving myself some options for this paper specifically. I have always had favorites, but wanted to truly pick one that stood out to me in this exhibit. After wandering around for a while I finally put my pen and notebook down, satisfied with my notes and confident I would choose one of the works I had seen.

We entered the last room of the exhibition, and I decided to just enjoy it, not focus on what I wanted to write about but to just enjoy the art of looking and letting my mind explore the room, the whispered hush of a security guard, the two ladies discussion which work relates more to the one they saw in Paris, and the dull tone of an informational video playing on the other side of the wall. Towards the center of the room I was enthralled by a clear case with sketches and prints scattered around and my attention was pulled to a small printed page. This was all that was left in color from a large scale mural, this small printed page, no bigger than a sketchbook page. I have heard of this mural, often using it to fuel my rage in the world of gallery curation and preservation but this moment brought those memories to a blinding halt. This image of Modern Woman (1892–93) from William Walton’s Art and Architecture (1893), on view in Mary Cassatt: After Impressionism at the Art Institute is the image I have chosen to focus on. Now from an outsider’s perspective, this piece, surrounded by so many beautiful not to mention finished pieces of mothers and children, portraits of ladies reading or picking fruit, all for this fragment to catch my utmost attention. Why? Because this fragment stands in the place of all that is lost, something lost amongst these works. This exhibition was built around a central room, surrounded by the missing painting, almost like a ghost in the room. While this may seem miniscule to the average view, to me it brought full circle the heaviness and admiration I feel towards Mary Cassatt. Cassatt was the only American and the only woman to exhibit with the French Impressionists, and with no doubt she fought her way there throughout her whole career. With Modern Woman we see her embarking on an unparalleled adventure to try something new, creating a monumental mural for the Woman’s Building at the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago. This mural stood 14 feet tall and 60 feet wide, a three part composition displayed in the buildings Hall of Honor and featured about 20 women and girls across a luscious landscape (Madsen, 2026).
It was such a surprise that Cassatt was chosen for this mural at all. She was almost 50 at the time, and had been painting for more than 30 years, but wasn’t well known in America (American Girls Art Club in Paris, 2014). As the painting hung, critics judged her and her conduct as a woman, stating her subject material was too trivial for such an occasion, while many women who saw it praised it for that exact reason. In her own words from a letter she wrote, “An American friend asked me in a rather huffy tone the other day, ‘Then this is woman apart from her relations to man!’ I told him it was. Men I have no doubt are painted in all their vigor on the walls of other buildings (Cassatt, as cited in Quinn, 2020)”. The three focuses of the mural from left to right were Fame, Knowledge, and Art, the largest being the print we are focusing on. This was a print of the young women picking fruit, the fruit of knowledge and science. This has so much richness to pull from. We can pull references from Adam and Eve and all the western stories that blame women for men’s fall from grace and purity. We can also see the generations in the images, much like so much of womanhood being passed down by our mothers before us. We see the generations after us being fed and formed by the fruits of our labor, whether that is good fruit, or bad fruit, it falls on the woman (Quinn, 2020).
I was flooded at this point, reading all the signs and taking as much of this glass case as a person could. To my left a video was playing, something I hadn’t been able to absorb when I first walked in. The video presented a wonderful biography of Cassatt, her trials and victories as an artist (Art Institute of Chicago, 2026b). One part stuck with me.
“Cassatt never travelled to Chicago to see her Mural Installed.”
How? Why? Imagine spending months working on a massive mural for a wonderful exposition, and not ever seeing it finalized. Why didn’t she go? Was it too trivial? Were people that harsh to her? Or was she just moving on to more engaging work for herself. I yearn to know what that was like. What was going through her mind and how could she not see it? With my mind rushing with questions I continued to watch, learning how the piece had been put into storage when the building was taken down, but has since been lost. The last it was seen was in 1912, and is said to have been in the possession of the Palmer House family, while others rumor, in hope I believe, that it is just sitting forgotten somewhere, waiting to be found (Art Institute of Chicago, 2026b).
This small piece of art has brought about so much inside me. I feel as though I had to work through a diverse palette of emotions to develop any sort of conclusion let alone a paper on this piece. I can not connect with this print, this story enough. The fact that my eyes will probably never get to see this original art often brings tears to my eyes, how silly is that. But also how honest is that. This is what art does, this is what art is. It connects us. It can bring two people, from two completely different times, and allow them to see each other in such an intimate and raw way. Mary Cassatt will always be an artist I look at too, from the way we both use deep blues in our shadows, or the way we find small ways to honor our womanhood, or the spunk she had when creating in the way she wanted to create. Her inspiration is something I see in my work everyday, and her courage to push through such a male-dominated art world and let her work be seen is something that can inspire all women.
This exhibition is part of an effort to recover women artists and bring to light some of the geniuses that have been excluded from history (Art Institute of Chicago, 2026a). Mary Cassatt is just one whose story is being told, there is so much more work to do. This exhibit is not only wonderful for those who love art, but for students, giving them an opportunity to see a different side of history, and as a cautionary tale of what history hides. This small plate reminds us not only of Mary Cassatt and the brilliant and boldly stated mural that hung in our great city, but also as a warning about what can get lost when we look at history from a single point of view.

References
American Girls Art Club in Paris. (2014, December 9). Mary Cassatt’s Chicago mural. American Girls Art Club in Paris . . . and Beyond. https://americangirlsartclubinparis.com/2014/12/09/mary-cassatts-chicago-mural/
Art Institute of Chicago. (2026a). Mary Cassatt: After Impressionism [Exhibition]. https://www.artic.edu/exhibitions/10487/mary-cassatt-after-impressionism
Art Institute of Chicago. (2026b). Modern Woman: Mary Cassatt’s mural for Chicago [Video]. https://www.artic.edu/videos/1594/modern-woman-mary-cassatts-mural-for-chicago
Madsen, A. K. (2026, September 1). Going big for Chicago: Mary Cassatt’s mural, Modern Woman. Art Institute of Chicago. https://www.artic.edu/articles/1276/going-big-for-chicago-mary-cassatts-mural-imodern-womani
Quinn, B. (2020, August 17). Mary Cassatt’s independent, feminist spirit. Hyperallergic. https://hyperallergic.com/mary-cassatt-she-votes/




Comments